Continue to Site

[SOLVED] Which is good Cyclone IV(Altera) or Sparten-3E (Xilinx)

Status
Not open for further replies.

ghegde

Member level 1
Member level 1
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
32
Helped
3
Reputation
6
Reaction score
3
Trophy points
1,288
Location
Singapore
Activity points
1,502
Hi
I need to buy a new FPGA board.Which board is good to buy?one with Cyclone IV(Altera) or Sparten-3E (Xilinx)?

Thanks in advance
ghegde
 

ghegde,

both are good devices.
Cyclone IV is cosidered "more advanced" as it uses newer silicon process than the Spartan 3 series.
Cyclone IV is better comparable to Spatan 6.

But when shopping for an FPGA evaluation board - you must consider other factors that are just as (and sometimes more) important than the device maker and specific family.

Base your decision on what you need:

1. Number of easily reachable GPIOs.
2. Debug connectors (for example : RS-232 or USB to UART).
3. On board peripherials and connector ( for example : VGA ).
4. FPGA logic density.
5. On PCB memory (FLASH and RAM)
6. Fast signals (if needed)
7. Features that enhance debugability (simple switches and LEDs).
8. On PCB A/D and D/A

For a first board I'd buy either DE2 or Spartan 3A/3AN starter kit.
Both boards are great starters - you can't go wrong with these.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ghegde

    ghegde

    Points: 2
    Helpful Answer Positive Rating
ghegde,

both are good devices.
Cyclone IV is cosidered "more advanced" as it uses newer silicon process than the Spartan 3 series.
Cyclone IV is better comparable to Spatan 6.

But when shopping for an FPGA evaluation board - you must consider other factors that are just as (and sometimes more) important than the device maker and specific family.

Base your decision on what you need:

1. Number of easily reachable GPIOs.
2. Debug connectors (for example : RS-232 or USB to UART).
3. On board peripherials and connector ( for example : VGA ).
4. FPGA logic density.
5. On PCB memory (FLASH and RAM)
6. Fast signals (if needed)
7. Features that enhance debugability (simple switches and LEDs).
8. On PCB A/D and D/A

For a first board I'd buy either DE2 or Spartan 3A/3AN starter kit.
Both boards are great starters - you can't go wrong with these.

Thanks a lot for your suggestion :)
I was comparing between https://papilio.cc/ and https://www.terasic.com.tw/cgi-bin/page/archive.pl?Language=English&CategoryNo=139&No=593.DE0-Nano is better right?

Thanks and regards
ghegde
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Welcome to EDABoard.com

Sponsor

Back
Top