D.A.(Tony)Stewart
Advanced Member level 7
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2007
- Messages
- 9,813
- Helped
- 1,854
- Reputation
- 3,709
- Reaction score
- 2,405
- Trophy points
- 1,413
- Location
- Richmond Hill, ON, Canada
- Activity points
- 62,991
When transistors saturate the Beta reduces to about 10% of the linear range or 10:1 (Ic:Ib) for most datasheets, although super junction ( See Diodes Inc) "ultra low Vce_sat_ devices can be as high as 50:1 in saturation. or 2% of the collector current and then usually have a linear Beta of 500.
EDIT
Your SIM had a solenoid,, but you are using a relay, please me correct your mistakes with specs. on motor, relay, etc. or rela part numbers or links.
With 1mA base current when the transistor comes out of saturation the Beta will increase to >100 typ. with 100mA on collector . If the Solenoid has a DC resistance of 10 Ohms, there will be 1V drop across the coil and 11V across the transister with 1.1W dissipation and it will fry without a large case (TO-220) then may need a heat sink.
Think of all switches, transistors and solenoids as switches with current gain ( output rating/ drive current) Relays can be very efficient as high as 5000 from OMRON while transistors can be very inneficient ( 10% drive or 10:1 gain)
That's why you need to provide a coil resistance spec. then increase your base drive from 2 to 10% of coil current, which may be at least 1 Amp to drive a 1HP motor. JUst a guess, it could be more)
So start all over with specs of ouput power of load, then solenoid then transistor then drivers. then power supply to start a proper design.
EDIT
Your SIM had a solenoid,, but you are using a relay, please me correct your mistakes with specs. on motor, relay, etc. or rela part numbers or links.
With 1mA base current when the transistor comes out of saturation the Beta will increase to >100 typ. with 100mA on collector . If the Solenoid has a DC resistance of 10 Ohms, there will be 1V drop across the coil and 11V across the transister with 1.1W dissipation and it will fry without a large case (TO-220) then may need a heat sink.
Think of all switches, transistors and solenoids as switches with current gain ( output rating/ drive current) Relays can be very efficient as high as 5000 from OMRON while transistors can be very inneficient ( 10% drive or 10:1 gain)
That's why you need to provide a coil resistance spec. then increase your base drive from 2 to 10% of coil current, which may be at least 1 Amp to drive a 1HP motor. JUst a guess, it could be more)
So start all over with specs of ouput power of load, then solenoid then transistor then drivers. then power supply to start a proper design.
Last edited: