JPR
Full Member level 1
As to your PS, I would suggest that internal vs external compensation should be selected based upon, among other things, the range (and type!) of capacitance expected at the output, the frequency response of internal nodes that might be used for compensation, and the requirements.
I would tend to agree that internal compensation can provide benefits, particularly since the capacitor at the output is likely to be one of the less robust components in the system. Assurance that things will still somewhat function if the capacitor fails is a good thing! However, the pole associated with the output capacitor MUST be considered when compensating the system, which means that an internally compensated system might be very slow, or very large (due to a large C1, which reduces the frequency of the pole for compensation purposes, and reduces the frequency of the zero to allow for cancellation with the pole at the output), or very complicated (with many poles and zeros, for example, to keep phase change to a minimum in order to maintain stability over a wide range of output capacitance)
In retrospect, I over-reacted to your statement, which seemed to trivialize the compensation of such a circuit, which, in the case of a high gain, low output resistance circuit, can be anything but trivial.
I would tend to agree that internal compensation can provide benefits, particularly since the capacitor at the output is likely to be one of the less robust components in the system. Assurance that things will still somewhat function if the capacitor fails is a good thing! However, the pole associated with the output capacitor MUST be considered when compensating the system, which means that an internally compensated system might be very slow, or very large (due to a large C1, which reduces the frequency of the pole for compensation purposes, and reduces the frequency of the zero to allow for cancellation with the pole at the output), or very complicated (with many poles and zeros, for example, to keep phase change to a minimum in order to maintain stability over a wide range of output capacitance)
In retrospect, I over-reacted to your statement, which seemed to trivialize the compensation of such a circuit, which, in the case of a high gain, low output resistance circuit, can be anything but trivial.