Try putting about 1 pF in parallel with R2. You can adjust the value for suitability. You almost always need to low-pass filter an op amp input, so that the input slew rate can't exceed the amp's capability. In simulations, you should also always adjust the input source's rise time to be somewhat realistic, or at least make it non-zero. (I would try different op amps, too.)
In a real circuit, you would also need a small X7R ceramic capacitor connected very close to pin 8 and to ground, and an electrolytic cap in parallel with it. You might also need at least a small resistance in the feedback path, close to the negative input pin, to damp any stray L or C. R3 should probably also be mounted close to the negative input pin. And, of course, don't make any "enclosed loop area" with your input and input ground conductors. Otherwise it might make a very good antenna, especially with the large-value resistance in the loop.