Even if the external load capacitance is not included in your test bench for the MCP660 op-amp, I examined its model and found it does include a 2 pf capacitance at its load. Hence, I suspect the reason you are observing a 60 mV increase in output amplitude with a 5 MHz input relative to the input amplitude and do not observe the 60 mV increase in amplitude relative to the input amplitude at 1 MHz is the transfer characteristic of the op-amp and its peripheral circuitry in your test bench.
Two options to attempt to confirm this hypothesis are:
1. Perform a small-signal AC analysis of your circuit with the input set to 1 V AC and observe the output voltage over frequency. This will illustrate the transfer function over frequency.
2. Apply a series of input frequencies and measure the gain at each frequency in a series of transient simulations to assemble the gain characteristic as a function of input frequency.