If you want to run an AC analysis in order to measure gain & phase, you must
break the feedback loop, which you didn't do in your simulation. Hence your (negative) transimpedance of -526Ω is superimposed by a positive one of +1kΩ (your feedback resistor), which probably causes this weird gain magnitude result.
You might want to study
this thread, and especially
my explanation attempt - which was wrong for that thread -, but might give you some enlightenment for your problem.
So
break your feedback loop - either by the LC method shown, or - even much easier - by using the STB (stability) analysis, breaking the feedback loop by an
iprobe.