Multiple dips on S(1,1) Plot- VNA results

You compare dB(S(1,1)) with VSWR. This is wrong. Change the measurement quantity being as dB(S) at VNA.

It is actually plotted in Matlab after taking data of dB(S) from VNA. I gave the title of db(S(1,1)) myself. This is the reflection coefficient plot of the antenna. What I want to ask is that what does this type of plot depict, with so many dips and abrupt changes? Is there any particular behavior that we can conclude from such result? I didn't have such changes in my simulation results.

We could understand the results better if we knew the antenna dimensions and test setup geometry. In case of doubt, the about 100 MHz delta corresponds to room reflections and feed cable common mode wave resonances. Presume you don't use anechoic chamber and effective common mode isolation?

Amra1 said:

It is actually plotted in Matlab after taking data of dB(S) from VNA. I gave the title of db(S(1,1)) myself. This is the reflection coefficient plot of the antenna. What I want to ask is that what does this type of plot depict, with so many dips and abrupt changes? Is there any particular behavior that we can conclude from such result? I didn't have such changes in my simulation results.

Click to expand...

You either have plotted in MatLab or by something different tool, no matter.
You HAVE to compare same quantities to able to compare the results and I still see two different quantities are in intention to compare. If you use a VNA, you can easily switch from VSWR to dB(S) then compare.

i have tested lots of antennas that have multiple S11 dips at different frequencies.
they do not necessarily mean that the antenna is "tuned" at any one of those dips!
what i like to also do is have a standard gain horn handy, and simultaneously measure S21 magnitude between the test antenna, and the standard gain horn maybe a foot away. when it get an S11 minimum, AND simultanelously an S21 magnitude maximum, THAT is where the antenna is tuned.

as an example of a spurious antenna response, lets say i made an "antenna" by soldering a 50 ohm chip resistor at the end of a piece of semirigid cable. It would have a very low S11 magnitude, right? but it would make very poor radiator. Similar sort of loss mechanisms can go on inside an antenna, where instead of radiating at an S11 dip, it might just be turning all the incident power into heat!

To me, those oscillations in S11 may indicate a poor VNA calibration. I would try the experiment again with a rigorous calibration, to verify the response.