Thanks for the reply!
That makes sense, since I was instructed to connect the output of a passive filter to a non-inverting op-amp to get this far. I was told that would yield an active bandpass (active= op-amp is an active element, bandpass= only certain frequencies are allowed to pass).
This is a project for school that will only be using the ideal conditions in the simulator. I have to find the RLC values given the center frequency of 6.8 MHz (and the bandwidth and gain), unless I can argue that the simulator cannot accomplish that. I am new at this, so what value of Q would be "reasonable"? I know that Q describes how underdamped the oscillation is.