Remember the following points
1. The conventional Wilkinson power divider is a narrow band device. So fix your frequency band of operation and try to optimize within those constraints. It would not be fruitful to try for anything over 20% bandwidth of operation.
2. Even if you assume no loss in the resistors, the maximum you can reach for |S12|, |S13|, |S14| or |S15| is going to be -6 dB (because total input = total output power). Due to power loss in the resistors, fabrication tolerances, resistor tolerances, substrate losses etc... you will generally end up with some more energy being lost. If you can get final HFSS simulation values better than -7 dB, that is very good.
3. |S11| < -20 dB is generally enough for most specifications. It is only for rare applications that you need |S11| to be any lower.
4. Ansoft Designer seems to be a circuit simulator and there is only a limited level of accuracy that you can achieve with it. Solve your design with HFSS and then we can get a closer prediction of real-world performance.