FlyingDutch
Advanced Member level 1
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2017
- Messages
- 458
- Helped
- 45
- Reputation
- 92
- Reaction score
- 55
- Trophy points
- 1,308
- Location
- Bydgoszcz - Poland
- Activity points
- 6,323
Hello,As I know, members start a post here looking for questions, suggestions, etc, and the thread ideally remains open for replies until is is marked 'Solved'.
But I do not understand the intention of your thread.
I am of the opinion that your post is more of a blog or promotion work type. EDA-Board has a separate Blog section which is more suited for such work.
Please do not get the wrong opinion that I am against your post.
Hello @KlausST,Hi,
My feedback:
On the PCB I see a lot of capacitors and/or resistors on the right side.
I can't find out their purpose.
But usually on FPGAs with high speed signals one wants the traces to be as short as possible.
So - for my taste - they are too far away from the FPGA.
Mind:
* the trace length causes impedance that can not be compensated by trace width/thickness
* it's not the true frequency (which depends on application) that causes EMI, but it's the signal rise/fall rate (for sure becomes multiplied by the frequency). Thus a long trace with just 1MHz may spread a lot of noise way above 1MHz. (And also pick up.. WiFi, cell phones, Bluetoooth...)
* a rock solid GND plane is a must.
Klaus
I thought the same.No ground plane?
Hi,No ground plane?
Hi,I thought the same.
Designing the green layer as GND plane should be less work than routing all the traces.
But I guess autorouter did the routing. Still don´t understand. So writing post#5 was a waste of time :-(
Klaus
A ground plane with holes for vias between other layers is much better than no ground plane.in "Easy EDA" CAD and in JLPCB company there is not "blind vias" available so I can't make full layer (cooper area) a ground plane.
Yes, this is an option worth consideringA ground plane with holes for vias between other layers is much better than no ground plane.
All my PCB layouts inlude a solid GND plane. Almost no PCB use blind vias.in "Easy EDA" CAD and in JLPCB company there is not "blind vias" available so I can't make full layer (cooper area) a ground plane.
Hi @KlausST ,Hi,
All my PCB layouts inlude a solid GND plane. Almost no PCB use blind vias.
Additional comments regarding layout:
* are you sure you want the vias in the SMD pads? In most cases you simply could avoid them.
* your power traces are rather small. May work for low currents... but for higher currents
* audio signals without DC blocking capacitor?
* why 680R in series with the push buttons? (I´d rather expect pull up)
* why 2k2 in series with the DIP switches? (I´d rather expect pull up)
* why 33R in series with the MODE switches?
* What´s R21 good for?
* Are you sure you don´t want OSC1 supply bypassed with a capacitor?
* Are you sure you want the LED current below 1mA?
Klaus
Added:
Usually one wants some mm gap between PCB outline and copper.
why 33R in series with the MODE switches?
these LEDs has 2mA nominal current.Are you sure you want the LED current below 1mA?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?