You will find that it is the length of the slit (lack of contact) that determines when the slits passes the higher frequencies, so your connection points or mounting points will provide (as a minimum) good contact points and determine the high pass nature of the 'gap'.
Conductive rubber of the right material can be a good solution as can beryllium copper fingers.
My concern with aluminium is the surface oxide layer (insulates) or the anodising protection which insulates, I think it is 'passivation?'
But my other concern is that it has to 100% cover, not just on one surface of a pcb for good EM screening. Even the PCB thickness will be a 'gap' for RF.
Electrostatic screening is a different issue, but then even a thin bit of foil will be good.
Hope this helps....