Well, Vgs is biased to be higher than Vth, in all cases. And Vds maybe should be higher than Vgs - Vt when it's pulled to the maximum of one direction?
I'm thinking maybe just the output conductances add-lowering the overall output resistance at Vout. Since the FET's have been approximately matched, this would equate to half the output resistance of one FET. Thus giving the required gain of 151.5? hmm
Does no one have any thoughts about solution/any of the other observations?