ghost896
Junior Member level 3
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2022
- Messages
- 26
- Helped
- 0
- Reputation
- 0
- Reaction score
- 0
- Trophy points
- 1
- Activity points
- 213
I don't have a problem with the material, sir, if I understand the logic, I can supply it. What I can't understand herecan your scope even see the output ?
View attachment 177215
A decent positive edge trigger pulse is needed - do you have the equipment for this ?
--- Updated ---
Thanks for your explanation, actually I know the marx generator you shared and I see that avalanche transistor is used here instead of spark gap. Normally, when the avalanche voltage is exceeded, the transistor will switch to avalanche mode, discharging the capacitors in series. But the part I don't understand is how the trigger starts this job.A variation of the Marx generator has spark gaps instead of transistors. These don't arc until voltage differential is great enough to overcome the gap.
The simulation below is among the menu of circuits in Falstad's animated interactive simulator. The yellow dots represent current bundles (or electrons, depending on how you wish to perceive it).
falstad.com/circuit
All capacitors charge in parallel, until their summed voltage is great enough to overcome all spark gaps, including the final output gap. Then all gaps fire simultaneously. The capacitors rapidly discharge in series.
We can suppose the authors of the document added a symmetrical section to provide a negative polarity to the final output pulse.
View attachment 177218
Thank you for your answer, sorry for my newness, I just really want to understand your logic so I'll ask where I'm confused if you'll excuse me.Maybe you have problems to see the function of T1 clearly due to the slightly confused drawing arrangement. You should be able to see that T1 Vce is falling from about Vcc to 0 during trigger, respectively it supplies pulses of +/- VCC/2 to both halfcircuits. The polarity is so, that Vce of T2 and T7 is increased by VCC/2. Avalanche breakdown of T2 and T7 triggers the other transistors in each chain.
--- Updated ---
O.K., I see a problem. To operate with 1V input trigger voltage, T1 must be in avalanche breakdown. A large pulse will run back to the trigger generator, potentially destroying it. The trigger pulse would be better applied through a transformer.
I can understand that the circuit works in the logic of the marx generator, but I can't understand the triggering part.A variation of the Marx generator has spark gaps instead of transistors. These don't arc until voltage differential is great enough to overcome the gap.
The simulation below is among the menu of circuits in Falstad's animated interactive simulator. The yellow dots represent current bundles (or electrons, depending on how you wish to perceive it).
falstad.com/circuit
All capacitors charge in parallel, until their summed voltage is great enough to overcome all spark gaps, including the final output gap. Then all gaps fire simultaneously. The capacitors rapidly discharge in series.
We can suppose the authors of the document added a symmetrical section to provide a negative polarity to the final output pulse.
View attachment 177218
Hello again sir, yes it does not see more than Vcc but I don't understand why you specifically mentioned it. If you could be more descriptive I would be very grateful.T1 sees no more than Vcc - look carefully at the diagram
Do you know how avalanche transistors work ?
Sorry, I don't understand
T1 is turned on then off to trigger the ckt - quite quickly - per the diagram supplied above ...
4) You suggested a transformer so as not to disturb the trigger source. Is this a different transformer than 1:1? So if the trig voltage rises to 30 volts (it looks like it in the Simulation) is it to keep the trigger pin within the withstand voltage range?The trigger pulse would be better applied through a transformer.
Hello,The circuit should not be viewed as having two outputs, one positive and one negative. It has one differential output, and the discharge should always be done between the two output connections, never to GND.
Othwerwise, strange things will happen around T1.
Going to the right in the circuit diagram the resistors will se a higher and higher voltage during the pulse. Resistors around T6 and T11 must handle the full output voltage (where do you find 10 kV resistors?), and that is not necessary if the capacitors are charged with resistors from the previous stage instead of having all resistors connected to VCC or GND.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?