...my apologies....i meant "LT1431", rather than "LT1241".
I never met the engineer....he told his company that it worked...i never saw it working.
what's wrong with the feedback?
the AD1280 should work okay.
...Thanks, it uses a Digital Isolator. (ADuM1280) ..instead of an opto to send the "feedback signal" back to the primary side.
As you know, this only gives essentially rough ON/OFF control.
isn't much different than an optical isolation.
...though i am sure you appreciate, its a digital isolator.....these cannot be used in a frequency compensated feedback loop design.
___________________--
Not only that, but with the digital isolator connected (effectively what the shown LT1713 comparator is) the way he has it, its the wrong polarity, it would need to be an inverting digital isolator.................i noticed on the PCB, that has has a wire going to the ADuM1280 secondary side Vcc pin (pin 1), because he forgot to put a PCB track to it...........so i actually suspect, that when he had it "working"...the digital isolator was not even powered, and the pull up resistor on the COMP pin was responsible for making it "work." [referring to schem of top post].......Aaaah...just seen in ADuM1280 datasheet that when pin 1 has no power, then the output of the digi isolator is high by default......this i now believe, is how he had it "working". (Also, i now see he had put a 10V supply into the ADuM1280, so he probably killed it.......so it wasnt really even "there"...and the COMP pin pullup resistor is what made it "work".
____________________
In his extremely brief notes, he did 'fess up about his 6.8uH inductor being too low in value.
He also reckoned he's got a turn-on spike problem....and says he increased LEB on the LTC3723-1 which gave a bit of help.
The transformer is Planar and has the shown inductances, and 1.2uH of leakage , measured at 10kHz......i saw that it cost £46 each, for 20 off.
____________________
Ive seen some of his other work...he obviously has potential....i suspect they had him in an environment where it was impossible for him to concentrate or something like that. Like many junior EE's, they are too shy and quiet to speak up when the environment is not conducive to their "concentrated effort."